Often all is not as it seems. This is especially common in business. Perception management is the true art of business, and urban planners of Tacoma, you have failed to sustain the perception that we are on the rise. Wired City, you have listened to a loud minority over the past 10 years and that should now come to an end. Fire up the grit and start reinventing yourself again. Back to the future we go.
Opposite and equal to our local right-wing ideology is the “let’s make Tacoma rad!” idealist. They have somehow justified and acted on principles that do not fit our region. Not yet anyway. Link light rail’s minimal positive contribution to our downtown has left a trench in the middle of the area’s potential commerce. The traffic flow between UWT and “old” downtown near the “old” Russell building is a joke. The idea of keeping cars to a minimum in downtown is a joke. The idea of Tacoma being rad right now is a joke. First comes infrastructure, then comes rad. This is just how it has to work.
Trying to model Tacoma after New York or San Francisco or Seattle is where the idealists’ rationale ends and their fantasy begins. We don’t have the established bustle of vibrant culture in our urban space and therefore need to focus on the ugly, brick & mortar details like traffic flow, destroying decrepit buildings (no matter their significance to rogue architects), courting big businesses to town, and simply doing all the things necessary to make downtown Tacoma attractive to big business.
Preserve that which is rationally preservable, and think green when convenient, but for now focus primarily on growth. Big growth. Professional services and administration, sure. Better yet, corporate headquarters and influential retail anchors like Whole Foods, REI, Costco, Best Buy, Safeway, Sports Authority, Nordstrom, Macy’s… dang, even Ross, TJ Maxx, Ikea or KMart could be a great start!
Boutique shops, record stores, salons and quaint cafes in Tacoma are the true favorites and the overall goal for most people. I still believe these businesses can’t make it on their own. You can’t have business without traffic. We have little traffic because we have few significant retail businesses. Chicken? Egg?
We slow the creation of profitable traffic when we cater to students and alternative methods of transportation. Most people would certainly agree that, in a perfect world, public transportation and walking or biking to work are all preferable to the single-occupancy vehicle operators clogging our thoroughfares. Cars are ugly, they’re loud and they smell funny. Unfortunately, they are also the primary means for people to buy things and take them away. It’s awfully hard for a guy to buy a TV or a computer or even a new wardrobe and take it home on his bicycle.
Tacoma seems an incubator for one thing and one thing only: food and drink. Why are bars and restaurants the only noticeable, new downtown businesses? NOT counting schools or government, try to come up with 5 significant, downtown retailers currently in business. I asked a few people to answer quickly:
“That cool antique toy store… you know the one I’m talking about? Um… retailers?” – N.C., Lakewood resident
“[laughs] 5 BIG retailers? In downtown Tacoma? Um… goose egg.” – P.C., route driver in downtown Tacoma
“Bullseye shooting range sells stuff.” – C.O., local web designer and prior tenant of downtown Tacoma office space
“Ha! This isn’t gonna be quick. Significant? LeRoy Jewelers?” – C.T., commercial real estate broker in South Tacoma
Extended sighs and pauses followed all of the above comments. The one person I asked who did name several downtown retailers included many that I certainly do not consider significant. If you succeeded in naming 5, my guess is that you either work downtown or you are currently enrolled at UW Tacoma or Bates Technical College. Most of us have a tough time naming 3.
The previous era of progress has waned; it is now time to fortify our stronghold. Repair, replace, regroup and reclaim. If you’re purebred Tacoman, you’ve been through this before, at least twice. For those of you who suffer from a “staying the same, means going backwards” mindset, think of this as a lateral move toward future success. Enhancing Opera Alley, the museum district, the light rail line, the north end of Pacific Ave or the Dock Street waterfront are all possibilities for commercial improvement. I say we start with one area and FOCUS on it. We need a large capacity for moving automobiles quickly and in large quantities, we need convenient proximity to freeway ramps and we need parking. We do NOT need more rail lines, bike lanes, parks or high-dollar condos.
P.S. Russell Investments, good luck in Seattle. I hope that aside from allowing you fancy, new digs, WaMu’s demise has also taught you plenty about deception, smoke n’ mirrors, and the idiocy running rampant on Wall Street.
RE: 5 retailers
Uh, can’t sorry. It’s all restaurants down there. What do you want, South Sound Running?
Lots to think about there. Though not a Tacoma native (Eastern Washington import, but my mother grew up here and Grandpa was a business owner on 6th Ave for decades), I’ve been here for 25 years. And I’ve gotten quite attached to my adopted burg. So here’s my take on the discussion.
First, we obviously need businesses that will bring jobs which pay decent wages. And that probably means some large companies. While I prefer supporting local, non-chain stores, that may not be enough at this time. But let’s be mindful of the climate we are trying to encourage and not be distracted by quick fixes that might come up. (I’m not knowledgable enough to offer suggestions here, just “philosophy”.)
Second, let’s take advantage of the growing activism and interest in the Dome District and focus there. It is close to the freeways, has parking available at the Transit Center, connects to other areas with various mass transit options with more coming soon), and has lots of available locations. And if there is a lot of focus here, we can head off some of the problems that Sound Transit says it is afraid of (transients, drug deals, etc.) if it builds the post and beam option supported by many in the community.
Third, when I saw the design offered for the Sound Transit bridge over Pacific Ave, I was reminded of the Community Walking Audit workshop I went to back in May. The current design is stark and uninviting. I immediately thought we should change the wide expanses of sterile concrete under the spans to a network of kiosks, cafes, tables for picnics, flower boxes, street trees, etc. to beckon pedestrians and cyclists to this area. Easy access via the Link, too! And what a difference to people arriving in Tacoma via Pacific Avenue. We would look charming!
Can we pull off something like this? That remains to be seen. But what we can imagine, we can manifest if we set our minds to it.
Patricia, you are a breath of fresh air. Thank you for your points and especially your examples. I am used to hearing a lot of generalizations backed with zero substance.
The dome district is a logical place to start. Access from multiple angles and freeways works for me, although there might not be enough residents in the immediate area to entice a large grocery market such as Whole Foods.
Other large retailers could fit nicely in the dome district, come to think of it. I like it.
More truth spoken by you: many first-time visitors to Tacoma have only the view from Pacific Avenue for a memory. We could absolutely use a better main drag.
Lots of thought in this thread.
This is bad in all respects for T-Town. It’s only middlingly good for Seattle.
In this economy, towns like Tacoma will suffer more than big cities.
It HAS to be homegrown. No major corporation is going to move to Tacoma – that is reality. It will take local chutzpah to make the promise a reality.
All in all, it’s sad.
Okay, say it’s homegrown. How do we attract retail? Why are we all restaurants all the time? We need your help down here, Weis.
Retail is overrated. Flagships are where it’s at.
Can Brown & Haley make some badass candy store?
I kinda like retail flagships. I also don’t believe there is such a thing as a “badass candy store” and again, I would really like to see something that doesn’t involve food downtown. No more ice cream, candy, cupcakes, bars, restaurants… Enough is enough.
I want a store where I can buy something tangible to take home with me. Anything. I’ve lived most of my 3.5+ decades in or near Tacoma. Would you believe I’ve NEVER bought any durable goods in downtown Tacoma. Ever. I was too young to shop at Schoenfeld’s, I wasn’t interested in the camera shop before it left (I would be now). I don’t like running, therefore I have no use for the running store. I have never had a reason to go to the Learning Sprout. I tried to look for a book or two at the UW Bookstore and they didn’t have what I needed. I’ve bought things in downtown Portland, Seattle, Salt Lake City.
Sad, really.